Priests who have served St. Peter's Parish

Rev. McDonough                              First priest to visit New Brunswick, 1825
Rev. John Powers                             Celebrated first Mass in New Brunswick, 1825
Rev. Joseph Schneller                      Constructed first parish church, 1829-1831

Rev. Bernard McArdle                  First resident pastor, 1833-1839
Rev. Madrono                                  Non-resident administrator, 1839-1843
Rev. Hugh McGuire                      Second resident pastor, 1843-1846

Rev. John Rogers                         First permanent resident pastor, 1846-1887

Rev. Myles C. Duggan                  Administrator, 1867-1873

Rev. J. J. Zimmer                              1872-1873
Rev. E. M. Hickey                             1873
Rev. Patrick Downes                    Administrator, 1873-1881
Rev. Vasallo                                    1875
Rev. D. M. Cartie                             1875-1876
Rev. Joseph Flynn                           1875-1876
Rev. Msgr. John O’Grady            1876-1879; Admin., 1881-1887; Pastor, 1887-1919
Rev. J. P. Whelan                            1879-1882
Rev. P. Dernis
Rev. Michael Malloy                          
Rev. Joseph Devine                        1882
Rev. William P. Cantwell                  1882-1885
Rev. William Fitzgerald                    1885-1890
Rev. William Miller                           1890
Rev. J. H. Kenny                             1893-1894
Rev. W. F. Dietrich                         1894-1895
Rev. Joseph A. Egan                      1895
Rev. McCorristin                             1899
Rev. Patrick J. Clune                      1899
Rev. James A. Healy                       1902-1904
Rev. Peter J. Kelly                          1902
Rev. James F. Morrison                  1902
Rev. W. J. Reddan                          1903
Rev. James Gough                         1904-1909
Rev. J. B. Conrad                           1904
Rev. James Caton                          1905-1906
Rev. Francis Quinn                        1907-1913
Rev. W. P. Waldron                         1911-1916
Rev. Aloysius McCue                      1916-1920
Rev. William Brennan                     1918-1928
Rev. John W. Norris                     Pastor, 1919-1928
Rev. Thomas Healy                         1920-1922
Rev. Michael Dalton                        1925-1926
Rev. William Quinn                          1926-1928
Rev. Joseph B. McIntyre                  1927-1934
Rev. Msgr. Peter J. Hart, P.A.      Pastor, 1928-1949 (pictured at right)
Rev. Msgr. Richard T. Crean          1928-1929
Rev. Edward A. McKenna               1929-1935
Rev. Francis Thornton                    1934-1935
Rev. Edward A. McAndrews            1934-1937
Rev. Thomas Kelsey                       1936
Rev. Francis J. Nolan                      1937-1942
Rev. Eugene V. Davis                     1937-1943
Rev. W. R. Yahner                          1939-1941
Rev. James Coyne                          1941-1942
Rev. Fulton Tehnan                        1941-1942
Rev. Joseph Hughes                       1942-1944
Rev. Francis P. J. Coan                   1943-1947
Rev. Theodore A. Opendaker         1944-1946
Rev. Michael J. Cetkowski               1944-1945
Rev. Henry M. Tracy                       1945-1948
Rev. Frederick Clancy                    1946
Rev. Thomas J. O’Dea                    1947-1950
Rev. Walter French                         1948
Rev. Michael Clark                          1948-1949
Rev. John P. Byrnes                       1948-1951
Rev. Earl Gannon                           1949-1950       
Rev. Msgr. James A. Harding     Pastor, 1950-1965 (pictured at right)
Rev. James A. Reilly                       1950-1956
Rev. Francis X. Donovan                1950-1958
Rev. Thomas C. Ryan                    1951
Rev. Joseph A. B. Wade                 1951-1957
Rev. Adam T. Kearns                     1956-1959
Rev. Hugh McGovern                     1958-1960
Rev. John J. Connolly                     1958-1961
Rev. Matthew Costello                    1959-1964
Rev. Msgr. William R. Capano        1961-1969
Rev. William Gardner                      1962-1969
Rev. Msgr. John J. Endebrock   Pastor 1965-1970

Team Ministry:                              1970-1974
Rev. James McGovern                    (1966)
Rev. Msgr. Anthony J. Gambino      (1968)
Rev. Msgr. Michael J. Corona         (1969)
Rev. Msgr. William J. Capik        Pastor, 1974-1981 (pictured at right)
Rev. Anthony J. Curran                  1974-1976
Rev. Msgr. Terrance M. Lawler      1974-1983
Rev. Robert J. Shelly                      1976-1978
Rev. Msgr. Liam A. Minogue       Pastor, 1981-1993 (pictured at right)
Rev. William J. Smith                       1982-1983
Rev. Charles O’Connor                   1983-1986
Rev. Msgr. Gregory E. S. Malovetz  1985-1986
Rev. John J. Casey                          1986-1988
Rev. Michael Venditti                       1987-1989
Rev. Stanley Gromadzki                  1989-1991
Rev. Joseph Hogan                         1990-1994
Rev. Robert Gorman                       1991-1992
Rev. Peter Suhaka                          1992-1995
Rev. Msgr. Joseph M. Curry       1986-1989; Pastor, 1993-2005
Rev. Michael Kottar                         1994-1996
Rev. Timothy Christy                       1996-1997
Rev. George Farrell                         1997
Rev. Timothy Lambert                     1998-1999
Rev. James McLaughlin                   1999-2002
Rev. Thomas A. Odorizzi, C.O.     Admin., 2005-2007; Pastor, 2007-present
Rev. Kevin P. Kelly, C.O.                 2008-2009
Rev. Jeffrey M. Calia, C.O.              2010-present